HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a vs MINISFORUM MS-A2

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a, front view
MINISFORUM MS-A2 viewed from the front in its black ventilated chassis
VS

Check current prices

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

Ryzen AI 7 PRO 450 / 32GB DDR5 / 1TB SSD / Windows 11 Pro

Search Amazon Amazon affiliate link

MINISFORUM MS-A2

Ryzen 9 9955HX barebone, US adapter

Check price Amazon affiliate link

Amazon results may include other models. Verify the processor, memory, storage, and seller before buying.

iThese are manufacturer-sourced specifications, not MiniPCBench test results. Confirm the exact processor, memory, storage, price, and availability before buying.
Memory
Storage

1Is it fast for normal work?

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Desktop and operating-system support Windows and Ubuntu tested

2Can it handle sustained work?

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • CPU performance mode Fast CPU, cooling-limited
  • Video encoding behavior No AV1 hardware encoding

3Can it game?

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Integrated-graphics capability Basic Radeon 610M
  • Add-in GPU limits Single-slot, bus-powered GPU

4Is it loud or hot?

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

  • Maximum observed CPU temperature Not available
  • Idle sound level Not available
  • Load sound level Not available

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Maximum observed CPU temperature 90 C
  • Idle sound level 39 dBA
  • Load sound level 50 dBA

5How much electricity does it use?

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Low-end idle wall power 25 W
  • Maximum observed wall power 160 W

6Can I upgrade and connect everything?

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

  • Memory is upgradeable Yes
  • Storage is upgradeable Yes
  • Thunderbolt is present Not available
  • Memory compatibility Not available
  • Network interfaces Not available
  • Storage expansion Not available

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Memory is upgradeable Yes
  • Storage is upgradeable Yes
  • Thunderbolt is present No
  • Memory compatibility 96GB official; 128GB tested
  • Network interfaces 2x 10GbE plus 2x 2.5GbE
  • Storage expansion 3x NVMe, including U.2

7Is it good value?

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

  • Manufacturer price Not available
  • Verified Amazon configuration Not available
  • Reviewer value tradeoff Not available

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Manufacturer price $799
  • Verified Amazon configuration B0F8JG2SHN
  • Reviewer value tradeoff Expensive, with little direct competition

8Will it be dependable?

HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

  • Seller warranty Not available
  • Sustained-load cooling Not available
  • Storage-lane default Not available

MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Seller warranty 2 years
  • Sustained-load cooling Throttling observed
  • Storage-lane default Gen 3 default

References

  1. HP US. EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a DZ1Q0UA#ABA specifications. Product page. Accessed .

    Configuration: Ryzen AI 7 PRO 450 / 32GB DDR5 / 1TB SSD / Windows 11 Pro

    Disclosure: Manufacturer specifications; no MiniPCBench measurements.

  2. MINISFORUM. MINISFORUM MS-A2. Product page. . Accessed .

    Configuration: MS-A200US: Ryzen 9 9955HX barebone, no RAM, no storage, no OS, US adapter

    Disclosure: Manufacturer specifications, current price, availability, warranty, and return terms.

  3. ServeTheHome. Homelab Perfection Minisforum MS-A2. Video review. . Accessed .

    Configuration: Ryzen 9 9955HX sample configured with multiple tested DDR5 capacities and NVMe storage, including 96GB ECC-function testing and 128GB non-ECC testing

    Disclosure: The description says the unit was purchased and contains Amazon affiliate links.

  4. Robtech. Powerful Mini PC Workstation - Minisforum MS-A2 Review. Video review. . Accessed .

    Configuration: Ryzen 9 9955HX configured sample with Crucial DDR5-5600, 2TB Crucial SSD, and Windows 11 Pro

    Disclosure: The description identifies the unit as a free review sample and contains retailer affiliate links.

Value for money

No value comparison is available. It requires eligible test scores and at least four current price observations in seven days.

Specification differences

Differences supported by the listed manufacturer specifications

Higher listed specifications for HP EliteDesk 8 Mini G2a

Higher listed specifications for MINISFORUM MS-A2

  • Supports 32 GB more memory

Verified specifications

Manufacturer-sourced specifications and current testing status

Processor

SpecificationEliteDesk 8 Mini G2aMS-A2
CPUAMD Ryzen AI 7 PRO 450AMD Ryzen 9 9955HX
Cores / threads8 / 1616 / 32
Processor default TDPNot disclosed100 W
Integrated graphicsAMD Radeon 860MAMD Radeon 610M integrated graphics

Memory and storage

SpecificationEliteDesk 8 Mini G2aMS-A2
Memory typeDDR5-5600 SODIMM, 1 x 32GB2x DDR5-5600 SO-DIMM slots
Maximum memory64 GB96 GB
Upgradeable memoryYesYes
Storage slots33

Connectivity

SpecificationEliteDesk 8 Mini G2aMS-A2
Ethernet1 x RJ-45; controller and link speed unconfirmed for this SKU2x 10GbE SFP+ (Intel X710) plus 2x 2.5GbE RJ45 (Intel I226-V and Realtek RTL8125)
WirelessMediaTek MT7925 Wi-Fi 7 and Bluetooth 5.4Wi-Fi 6E (MediaTek RZ616) + Bluetooth 5.2
USB4YesNo
ThunderboltNoNo

Size and price

SpecificationEliteDesk 8 Mini G2aMS-A2
Enclosure volumeNot published1.78 liters
List priceNot published$999
Product classNot assignedHome labs and compact servers